# Third-phase review before implementation

All eight task-root lodge images were opened. Existing commons exterior/rear/interior previews and the development-house preview were inspected. A fresh commons seed 6 baseline pair and four views are being retained separately from earlier evidence.

No serious flaw in the requested architecture was identified. The composition protocol, scoped effects, public attachment interfaces, actual-geometry validators and paired persistence can accommodate the proposed changes. Limited roof vocabulary and sparse furnishing are component/rule deficiencies, not a reason to replace the kernel. The stop condition remains applicable if subsequent work reveals a serious architectural issue.

Priorities: layered roof profiles and genuine roof attachments, usable sheltered balconies, deeper timber framing, furnished functional spaces with preserved circulation, coherent local garden edges. Preserve existing clients and all tests; no reference source reuse. The existing integer player/lighting/support models remain explicit approximations, not Minecraft simulation or structural engineering proofs.

Implementation and finite visual evidence will be recorded here without replacing previous phase reports.